The Irishman — cinematic still
The Criminal Gentleman

The Irishman

Film · 2019 · Directed by Martin Scorsese · Robert De Niro, Al Pacino, Joe Pesci, Harvey Keitel

Original interpretation — not a still from the production

Three and a half hours on loyalty and its bill.

The Continental Verdict

Essential

Martin Scorsese’s magisterial return to the world of American organised crime is less a celebration and more a elegy, a mournful epic charting the life of Frank Sheeran, a hitman for the Bufalino crime family and confidant to Jimmy Hoffa. Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci, and Al Pacino, titans of the genre, reunite here in roles that eschew the youthful swagger of their earlier collaborations for a more poignant, reflective, and ultimately sombre portrayal of ageing men grappling with the consequences of their choices. The film unfolds with a quiet intensity, its length allowing for a profound meditation on the passage of time, the erosion of allegiances, and the ultimate solitude that awaits those who live by a violent code.

Scorsese, working with cinematographer Rodrigo Prieto, imbues the narrative with a sense of fading grandeur, moving from the bustling mid-century American landscape to the quiet despair of later life. The de-ageing technology, initially a point of discussion, quickly recedes into the background as the performances take hold. Harvey Keitel and Ray Romano lend gravitas in supporting roles, further enriching a cast that feels like a gathering of old friends, here to tell one last, weighty tale. It is a work that demands patience and attention, but rewards it with a profound, almost Shakespearean exploration of power, betrayal, and the lingering shadow of the past.

Why Watch It

A film that examines the moral compromises and ultimate loneliness of those involved in organised crime, particularly in the latter half of the 20th century. It offers a reflection on loyalty, betrayal, and the unforgiving passage of time for men who live by a violent code.

The Gentleman Factor

The film presents a cautionary tale of a life spent in the shadows, highlighting the deceptive allure of power and the heavy toll it exacts. It’s a study in quiet desperation and the erosion of companionship, prompting a contemplation on what truly endures beyond fleeting material gain. An examination of brotherhood, however twisted, and the weight of legacy.

Look Out For

  • Mid-20th century American organised crime aesthetic
  • Sombre, reflective tone
  • De-aged actors for period flashbacks

The Locations

Pennsylvania (various cities including Philadelphia and Wilkes-Barre), upstate New York, Miami, Chicago, Detroit, Washington D.C.

More from the travel pages →

The Cars

Various American saloons and sedans from the 1950s, 60s, and 70s, reflecting the period.

More from motoring →

The Wardrobe

Christopher Peterson’s costumes are meticulously researched, evolving from sharp suits and fedoras of the mid-century to more relaxed, yet still impeccably tailored, sportswear in later decades. Observe the subtle shift in power dynamics reflected in the characters' evolving sartorial choices, particularly the understated authority conveyed by Russell Bufalino's wardrobe.

More on style →

The Soundtrack

A curated selection of period-appropriate popular music, carefully integrated to enhance the narrative's emotional depth and historical context, rather than merely providing nostalgic wallpaper.

Into the music room →

Watch Next

Where to Watch

Netflix

For the Collection

Also in The Criminal Gentleman

crimedramabiographical

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links cost you nothing and never influence what we recommend. Recommendations are honest and never paid for. Imagery is an original interpretation, not a still from the production.